Analytical Comparison Prose Extract and Film Scene

There are a number of similarities and differences in between the film extract of Ray Mears' Extreme Survival season 2, episode 6 (3:43 to 5:06) and page 149 of Touching the Void by Joe Simpson. The main similarity is the context of the narrative perspective: both individuals are alone in an isolated environment and they have to use their skills to survive.

The two pieces focus on their surroundings numerous times but it is the manner in which they do it that contrasts them. In Mears' documentary, the key way of describing the atmosphere is sound while in the Simpson's Touching the Void it is adjectives. Mears utilises non-diegetic, asynchronous, and calm background music to set the peaceful tone of the film. It has a slow rhythm and goes hand in hand with the diegetic, asynchronous atmospheric sounds such as waves, birds, and rustling leaves. Close-up, slow-paced shots focusing on select, beautiful nature elements also creates a paradise-like atmosphere.

On the other hand, Simpson uses diction to create a contradicting atmosphere. He does this through words that connote darkness such as "dead and lumpy", "dark of the cave", "dreamless black stupor", and "unmercifully". The use of such gory words create gruesome images in the mind of the viewer and allows them to empathise with Joe's tragic situation.

In conclusion, both Mears and Simpson display their surroundings and what they are overcoming to survive but with two very different tones. While Mears shows his surroundings like it is heaven on Earth, Simpson reveals his uncomforting situation.

(15 minutes)